The constant
battle between Joker and Batman is deeply rooted into the graphic novel genre.
Though different adaptations came arisen through the decades, like children’s
cartoons and more mature films. This piece goes into Joker’s mind. As
terrifying as that may seem, it is and more. Joker may well be a tragic
anti-hero of sorts. His philosophy is something to examine.
First, the art
work. I am certainly no art critic, but the focus seems to be on the emotion,
which seems to be standard. I cannot compare this piece to something like
Gaiman’s Sandman series; those are worlds apart and built upon different
things. Killing Joke, the focus is primarily on action, but there is time for
the philosophy.
Speaking of
philosophy: Joker’s insight on society, as cynical as it is, it true from his
experience. His own backstory is certainly solid enough to provide a foundation
for his perspective. Joker’s perspective hearkens to Poe’s and Hawthorne’s dark
romanticism where humanity makes life intolerable to itself. Perhaps Joker is right:
maybe there is no sense to life if all humanity does is break itself down to
rise above. But rise above what?
Why is one form
of madness preferable to another? Joker admits he went crazy, but humanity is
far more twisted and hypocritical. If governments can get away with killing
thousands and gain something from it, why can’t an individual? This seems Joker’s
perspective, but only on a surface level.
Joker hinted at another failing of humanity:
its fragility. His strongest point was what triggered World War 2: other
countries decided Germany had too many telegraph poles. In context Germany was
left if shambled after World War 1 and took a madness to restore it and nearly
bring the world down in flames. Perhaps Joker is being vague, but in attempting
to decipher his rants, let’s consider that politics is a form of madness itself
(which it is!).
Joker is right
in this regard: the humanity is unjust to itself. With his reference to
Germany, consider that Hitler gave the German people a false hope to realistic it
turned into madness that scorched the world. What may be good for the goose is
likely not good for the gander.
Sometimes, it
takes a monster in the dark to show you the importance of the light.
In summary,
Joker is an amalgamation of humanity’s weaknesses. We try to do what we can to
survive, but that is all we do and often worse. Eking out a living in a society
that sees an individual’s worth by their income is damned near impossible and
leads to depression in many cases.
I find it odd
when Joke jumped into the polluted river he was baptized. He came out with a
cynical but ultimately true perspective. In an odd way, he was reborn knowing
the truth and it drove him mad.
“Notice the
hideously bloated sense of humanity’s sense of importance” (Joker, Batman, the Killing Joke.) As much as
one would hate to agree with a psychopathic madman, he is right. Pride is an
ugly thing. And one vice leads to another. Pride comes before the fall.
As far as I liked
this piece, I couldn’t grasp the ending. Maybe. The more I think about it, the
more it seems like Batman was killed by humanity’s own ego and selfish desires.
Joker is right, humanity enjoys its own filth.
Joker is not an anti-hero. Sure, he is right in the aspect that humanity (and most definitely Gotham) are rife with corruption and moral filth, but he also doesn't take into consideration the kindness humanity is capable of as well. Joker is psychotic, and while he does have a certain point, the world -- and humanity -- aren't black and white. They're grey.
ReplyDeleteI like your perspective on the Joker and your analogy to the world/politics. It makes sense. You've done a lot of deep thinking here and I like your argument on that.
ReplyDeleteI agree that this particular graphic novel tried to show a more serious side to the series.
I like your point about how sometimes it takes a monster in the dark to show you the importance of light. It's a play off of the whole idea, "it's better to have loved and lost than never loved at all." How can you know good if you don't understand the bad? How can you appreciate happiness if you've never been sad? Maybe that's the true thing that separates heroes and villains: heroes can remember the good but villains are stubborn and focus only on the bad.
ReplyDelete