Dirty Birdie!
One thing that was most present,
though subtle, was how Annie and Paul became reflections of each other, with
Annie being the darker reflection. Both are academically inclined, but that is
where the comparison ends.
Annie, visibly displays
bipolar disorder. Perhaps this garners her some sympathy, perhaps not. Her
instability and obsession with Paul makes her more dangerous. Her personality
seems to be trifold: she has this caring side to her, a vindictive, wrathful
side, and a side that seems to be a mix of both. In a strange and dangerous
way, Annie has childish tendencies which is coupled with her callous side.
Annie is more complex
than what most would view her. If taken from the context of the story, Annie
has a child-like spirit to her, one that enjoys stories, but not how they are
made. She gives herself to a story, and given the way she laments Misery’s
passing giver Annie this innocent sparkle to her character. However, shadows
have a way of not letting go.
Paul on the one hand is
more simple and straightforward of a character, who at time mirrors Annie with
his intent to do harm, but this is for self-preservation. He even contemplates
it, which in and of itself is psychopathic behavior. His reason and fear are at
constant ends, adding to his frail condition. He lapses into episodes where he
teeters on the edge of insanity.
I could not help but draw
a connection between Misery and Jane Eyre. I see Annie and Paul in a similar
light to Jane as they are victims of circumstances beyond their control. For
Paul, his circumstance is his car accident, for Annie it is a bit obscure but
societal pressure is a strong reason for Annie’s mental state as it may have
been for Jane Eyre. In Jane Eyre, Jane is more of a prize to be had, it’s very
much the same in Misery.
For the part that did the
most damage: the writing. King has this method where he delves into the minds
of his characters and moves on; he says what needs to be said and moves on.
King’s use of language reflects his characters: he only speaks when his
characters cannot do so for themselves.
Going further into the
writing, King maintains his focus on Paul as if Paul is retelling the story in
Third-Person. This adds a certain air to it, as if as the story is progressing,
the line between Paul’s psyche and the narration merge and become nearly indistinguishable
from each other.
Overall, Misery is
certainly aptly titled. King weaves a menacing story that does not relent. Anne
may be the more complex character in this novel, but I think my bias for
antagonists is showing. Or maybe I’m just imagining Kathy Bates as Annie as I
read this?
I really enjoyed your study of Annie's psyche. I guess because, as you said, the book is written from Paul's POV and I got so caught up in the brilliance of King's showing Paul's gradual mental decline without ever telling us anything, that I didn't give Annie much thought. She is complex, and certainly has that child-like quality you described. For me, though, it was never enough to garner any sympathy. I don't think I ever felt anything for Annie but disgust. She was a "bad seed" as a child and never really changed.
ReplyDeleteI liked that someone else pointed out Annie's personality. While she may have never had a traumatic childhood or catalyst for her psychopathic behavior, I still felt for her. Sure, Paul is being forced to write against his will, but I understood Annie's desire, a reader's desire to become engrossed by words, to be consumed and pleasantly surprised. So, while Annie surely wasn't meant to be a sympathetic character, I understand, in a way, her literary desire.
ReplyDeleteGoing into the different facets of Annie's personality is a great approach, and I would love to see what a psychologist might say about her. I could see points where King started to make sympathetic points, but it was never enough in comparison with her aggressive psychotic tendencies. If she began these actions as a child, I think there was always something off in her brain chemistry. She's a dark entity in my opinion, so there wasn't many options other than to get rid of her.
ReplyDeleteKing certainly does come up with some catchy phrases, doesn't he? "Dirty birdy" in Misery, "Dirty Pillows" in Carrie. Interesting.
ReplyDeleteI liked when you analyzed Annie's childlike persona. I picked up on it, but didn't really think about it in detail until reading your post. It does up the sympathy factor (even though I didn't, and still really don't, feel badly for her) and the creep factor. After all, aren't children some of the most chilling antagonists? Example: Pet Cemetery. King knows what he's doing.